Broken heart

Palestine, Gaza, the West Bank, Israel

Map of Gaza showing urban areas, refugee camps, border crossings, and the Israeli-declared buffer zone. The Mediterranean Sea borders the 41 kilometer (25 mile) long northeast border of Gaza; Egypt is on the 10km (6 mile) southeast border; and Israel is along the southwest and northwest border.

It is with a broken heart that I watch what is happening in the Middle East, the latest iteration of a seemingly endless cycle of violence and destruction that has been occurring for longer than I've been alive. For me, the saddest aspect of this is the huge number of civilians on all sides that have been caught up in these cycles of violence for decades, killed, maimed, displaced.

I absolutely condemn the atrocious act of terrorism perpetrated by Hamas primarily against innocent Israeli civilians on October 7, 2023, killing at least 1,195 and wounding more than 5,000, and by holding 251 of them hostage, 100 of whom are still held hostage as I write this. I also condemn that Hamas continues to espouse the goal of destroying Israel.

However, after October 7, 2023 and over the subsequent weeks, months, and now more than a year, I have grown increasingly horrified by Israel's retaliatory war and the way it so blatantly disregards the lives and welfare of Palestinian civilians in attacks that killed more than 40,000 in the first year alone, likely many more, and that have displaced as much as 90% of the more than two million people living in Gaza.

Most civilians in Gaza are without adequate clean water, food, sanitation, and medical care. Israel continuously directs them to leave certain areas into other areas that are supposed to be safe zones, but then has bombed those areas, killing displaced civilians. In one year, more than 60% of Gaza's buildings have been damaged or destroyed, including most of its hospitals, universities, and schools.

I also am appalled by the way the Israeli so-called "settlers" are killing and displacing Palestinians in the West Bank, and the way the Israeli government is forcibly displacing Palestinians from East Jerusalem.

Of course, the roots of this current war go back more than a century. For details, jump down to Alternative timeline ∨.

This must end. We must find a path forward towards peaceful coexistence.

My heart is with the ordinary civilians who all deserve dignified and safe lives.

Jump to:

Ongoing reflections – Year 3

A note about the timeline

Each entry in these ongoing reflections is introduced with the date the item was published, followed by the number of days since Hamas carried out its act of terrorism on October 7, 2023 and Israel retaliated with its full-scale war on Gaza. However, it would be reasonable to list alternate dates for the start of this ongoing war that, counting from October 7, 2023, would add between 16 and 141 years (adapted from the Israeli–Palestinian conflict⩘  article in Wikipedia).

In particular, a crucial and devastating timeline event is the 1948 Palestine war, referred to by the Palestinians as the Nakba⩘  ('the catastrophe'). The Nakba occurred 75 years before the beginning of Israel's current war on Gaza, triggered by the Hamas attack of October 7, 2023.

For timeline details, jump down to: Alternative timeline ∨ 

See also: Before October 7th: Understanding the Long History of Israel's Assault on Gaza⩘  by Independent Jewish Voices Canada (IJV), Sep 27, 2024. IJV is "a grassroots organization grounded in Jewish tradition that opposes all forms of racism and advocates for justice and peace for all in Israel-Palestine".


∧ Top
Ongoing reflections – Year: < 1 · < 2  ·  4 >

Ongoing reflections


∧ Top
Ongoing reflections – Year: < 1 · < 2  ·  4 >

Related

Wikipedia articles

Historical perspective

Palestine, Israel and International Law⩘ , written evidence, UK Parliament Foreign Affairs Committee Inquiry, 'The Israeli-Palestinian conflict', submitted by Dr Ralph Wilde, Professor of International Law, University College London (IPC0022), dated Dec 25, 2024, published Feb 18, 2025.

Dr Wilde's insightful paper covers twelve points, beginning with:

  1. More than century-long denial of self-determination of, and war against, the Palestinian people, on the basis of racism.

The Palestinian people have been denied the exercise of their legal right to self-determination through the more-than century-long violent, colonial, racist effort to establish a nation-state exclusively for the Jewish people in the land of Mandatory Palestine.

When this began in earnest after the First World War, the Jewish population there was 11 per cent. Forcibly implementing Zionism in this demographic context has necessarily involved the extermination, or forced displacement, of some of the non-Jewish Palestinian population; the exercise of domination over, and subjugation, dispossession and immiseration of, remaining non-Jewish Palestinians; the emigration to that land of Jewish people, regardless of any direct personal link; and the denial of Palestinian refugees the right to return. All operating through a racist distinction privileging Jewish people over non-Jewish Palestinian people.

This has necessitated serious violations of all the fundamental rules of international law: the right of self-determination; the prohibitions of aggression, genocide, crimes against humanity, racial discrimination, apartheid, and torture; and the core protections of international humanitarian law.

Dr Wilde's paper goes on to cover the following points:

  1. Palestinian self-determination under Article 22 of the League of Nations Covenant
  2. Self-determination in international law after the Second World War—an additional right
  3. Nakba in 1948—violation of self-determination, and creation of a regime involving an ongoing violation of this right, as well as racial discrimination and apartheid, and a denial of the right to return
  4. 1967 Israeli capture of the Palestinian Gaza Strip and West Bank
  5. Illegal racial domination—apartheid—from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea
  6. Gaza Strip and West Bank as Palestinian territory—consequently, Israel's purported annexation, and attempted colonization, are illegal
  7. Self-determination as a right to be self-governing, requiring the occupation to end immediately
  8. The occupation as an illegal use of force in the law on the use of force
  9. Legal right to resist vested in the Palestinian people
  10. Illegal force does not become lawful in response to resistance to it
  11. Israel cannot lawfully use force to control the Palestinian territory for security purposes/pending a peace agreement

Books

Films

Additional notes


∧ Top
Ongoing reflections – Year: < 1 · < 2  ·  4 >

A note about the timeline

Each entry in these ongoing reflections is introduced with the date the item was published, followed by the number of days since Hamas carried out its act of terrorism on October 7, 2023 and Israel retaliated with its full-scale war on Gaza. However, it would be reasonable to list alternate dates for the start of this ongoing war that, counting from October 7, 2023, would add between 16 and 141 years (adapted from the Israeli–Palestinian conflict⩘  article in Wikipedia).

Alternative timeline

See also: Before October 7th: Understanding the Long History of Israel's Assault on Gaza⩘  by Independent Jewish Voices Canada (IJV), Sep 27, 2024. IJV is "a grassroots organization grounded in Jewish tradition that opposes all forms of racism and advocates for justice and peace for all in Israel-Palestine".


∧ Top
Ongoing reflections – Year: < 1 · < 2  ·  4 >